Feedback – And –Error Treatment In Communicative Language –Teaching Strategy

Some people have considered  the language of the second language  learner as other than a defective   ,distorted or incorrect form of the language they are learning . This has triggered off a number of research aimed  at investigating  objectively the whole phenomenon of second language use. To understand and appreciate the second language acquisition  is…


Some people have considered  the language of the second language  learner as other than a defective   ,distorted or incorrect form of the language they are learning . This has triggered off a number of research aimed  at investigating  objectively the whole phenomenon of second language use. To understand and appreciate the second language acquisition  is to treat the learner  language as a phenomenon to be studied  in its own right.

It is in fact that learners learn  a  second language  besides their mother tongue usually in the classroom. At every stage of the acquisition process, every language learner  has a language  his/her language behavior is consistent in certain respects at a given point in his /her  linguistic development but inconsistent  in others. The fact that  his/her language is improvised  or deficient  as a means of  communication  is  obvious , the errors referring to the learner’s  language  intuitions  about grammatically possessed by speaker of that  language. The learner language, while  having certain  characteristics of the target language, is manifestly different. It is variable and dynamic , changing all the time, because the learner’s linguistic  rules are  constantly undergoing revision. The learner language  is also called  interlanguage, a dialect  the learner produces  when attempting  at communication. While this language is similar to other learner  languages, It is different  from the language of the native speaker, hence  the  term interlanguage. In the  context of the language teaching discourse, errors characterize the differences between  the learner language  and the target  language as spoken  by native speakers.

Insights drawn from  the interlanguage  and error analysis  theories have considerable  impact  on the communicative  teaching strategy’s  fundamental  principles is that it ‘forbids’  direct correction of speech errors and makes the language teacher ‘accept’ structurally erroneous utterances. This principle is based on the assumption  that  the learner’s errors, just as the first  language acquisition, are caused  the processes of hypothesis testing ; these  errors are  transitional because they tend to disappear as the learner proceeds along the learning continuum, getting more language  input  and constantly revising and correcting erroneous  hypotheses.

Feedback  related to the learner’s language  is the other essential  function of language teaching  within  the framework of the communicative strategy . This feedback  is provided  primarily  by the teacher, but it may  also be supplied  by the learner’s classmates . It relates only  to the contents of the messages that the learner is transmitting and  not to their  grammatical form . Thus ability to communicate becomes  the main criterion  of success and the  learner gets  positive feedback whenever  his/ her  interlocutor  can understand his/her  intended message  in spite of the fact that the grammar form of the message  may be highly incorrect. As a consequence  the feedback  never explicitly  refers to the structural quality (grammaticality) of the learner language .Directing the learner’s attention to the grammatical correctness of his /her language  means diverting  it from  what ought to be his/her main concern, which is the expression and negotiation of meaning.

Fanslow distinguishes  two different goals  in the use of error  treatment forms: (a) immediate correction  of an error  and (b) Ultimate teaching  and learning of the correct form. He stresses that   errors are  normal part  of language learning  and are to be  corrected only  when they impair communication.

By: Geraldine C.. Flores I Teacher III I Pagalanggang National High School I Dinalupihan, Bataan